• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

NICABM home pageNICABM

Better outcomes. More quickly.

  • Home
  • Courses
  • Experts
  • Blog
  • Course Login
  • Contact

Is Your Patient “Feeling” Unworthy? What May Be the Underlying Cause, with Janina Fisher, PhD

34 Comments

Trauma can leave a patient with a deep sense of unworthiness. On top of that, your client might even blame themselves for feeling this way.

But as we know, there’s always a purpose behind a patient’s response to trauma. And sometimes, the challenge is getting your patient to see the wisdom behind their response – especially when that response is fueling shame and self-blame.

In the video below, Janina Fisher, PhD shares a trauma-informed way of framing a patient’s sense of unworthiness.

She’ll also walk you through specific language you can use with clients who insist on their unworthiness after trauma.

Take a look.

 

 

Click here for full transcript
“The feelings of shame, unworthiness, self-disgust, and fault, all make sense in the context of trauma.But here’s the thing that’s interesting about unworthiness: it’s really a belief. There is not emotion of unworthiness. Unworthiness is a belief: “I am worth nothing. I am worth less. I am worth less than nothing.” And that belief is a survival defense, part of the total submission response. The collapsing, numbing, loss of energy goes with the belief, “I’m not worthy,” and facilitates total submission because if we were thinking, “Wait a minute, you can’t do this to me. I’m a person of worth,” we wouldn’t collapse, we wouldn’t go numb, and therefore having to submit would be ten times more painful.And often clients fight with me – they say, “You don’t understand. You’re talking as if worthlessness is a belief. I am unworthy, that’s a fact. And if you don’t get that, you have failed me.” What kind of position does that put the therapist in? “If you don’t believe I’m unworthy, you will fail me.” And the therapist is thinking, “But if I do believe you’re unworthy, I’ve failed you.”So many of my colleagues and students have talked about that struggle in which they end up saying, “No, you’re worthy.” And the client says, “No, I’m not.” “Yes, you are.” “No, I’m not.” Which never gets us anywhere. But if I say to the client, “Well, obviously we have different assumptions. Your assumption is that it is absolutely true that you are unworthy, and my assumption is it’s absolutely true that believing you are unworthy was a brilliant survival strategy.” And then the client will say, “But your assumption is wrong. It is true.” And I say, “Well, I think my assumption is true.” And the client will say, “No, my assumption is true.” And then I usually say, “You know, you’re sticking to your story and I’m sticking to my story. Your story is you really are unworthy. My story is believing that was a great way of surviving. We have two different assumptions so let’s just make room for both.”Now you might not think that was making progress, but as soon as there’s room for two different viewpoints in the environment, that’s progress. Because it’s different from, “I’m unworthy.” “No, you’re not.” The client and I have agreed – they’re sticking to their story, and I’m sticking to my story.One of the interesting things is that clients rarely ask, how is unworthiness a survival strategy? Well, once we have agreed that we each have a different assumption – they rarely ask but if they did, the way I would address that is I would say, “What if you had believed that you were worthy and that it was wrong to treat you that way?” I say, “What if you had looked your father straight in the eye as if to say, ‘You are a bad man.'” And they shudder with fear, and I say, “So, it wouldn’t have been safe to have felt worthy. And so, what did happen as a result of your feeling unworthy?” And they say, “I did what I had to do.” And I say, “Okay, can we agree that the result was that you did survive?” And usually, that, we can both agree on.

I should say sometimes, clients will say, “You think this is surviving? I got to live so I could be tortured by shame for the rest of my life?” And I say, “Well, that’s why we’re here – so that you can say, ‘I’ve survived and I’m not tortured by shame.’”

 

For a more in-depth look at how to work with the collapse/submit response, check out the Advanced Master Program on the Treatment of Trauma.

In this 5-part program, the experts go beyond the fight-flight-freeze model and look at several emerging defense responses to trauma – including please & appease (also known as fawn), attach/cry-for-help, and collapse/submit.

Take a look here.

Now we’d like to hear from you. How do you work with patients who are stuck in the collapse/submit response? Please let us know by leaving a comment below.

If you found this helpful, here are a few more resources you might be interested in:

Helping Clients Talk About Shame

How Feeling “Never Good Enough” Can Get Passed Down Through Generations

[Infographic] – Four Key Ways Collapse/Submit Can Present in a Client

 

Shares440FacebookTweetLinkedInEmailPin

Related Posts: Anxiety, Healing Trauma, Nervous System

Please Leave A Comment Cancel reply

34 Comments

  1. R Townsend, Another Field, Chino Valley, AZ, USA says

    Thank you, this gave me a new way to look at things. I really appreciate your video!

    Reply
  2. Anonymous says

    Thank you so much for sharing, I truly appreciate it as it gives me a better understanding of my own shame and when others shame themselves

    Reply
  3. Mickey, Counseling, Toms Ricer, NJ, USA says

    This was a great approach to someone feeling they are unworthy….I like how you showed the client That her or his ability to respond with survival makes them worthy!

    Reply
  4. Dr. Karen L. Dallas, Medicine, CA says

    Great stuff!
    I literally just helped my 90 yr old great auntie (a retired RN & MSW) heal her past story of unworthiness!! Just in time for her 90th birthday.
    It is literally never too late to be set free or to set someone free!! She’s loving her new life of love & worthiness! And it’s only been about 5 weeks!

    Reply
  5. Trish Storrier, Counseling, AU says

    It would differ with each client of course, depending on the level of rapport and trust between us, their history, vulnerability, safety & openness.
    I would probably initially comment on what I had noticed; that it appears in response to (whatever the traumatic event was) that you have collapsed and submitted.
    I would initially ask what purpose they think that response may have served – at the time.
    I would invite them to consider what other options were available to them – at that time – and what the possible consequences/outcomes of those options may have been.
    I would then ask if they thought differently about their collapse/submit response now, after consideration.
    Depending on their engagement I may now invite them to consider what the possible consequences may be of remaining in that mode of collapse and submit now. I may then ask if they may be curious about considering the consequences of exploring alternative responses if and when they felt safe to do so and how I may support them to do that.

    Reply
  6. Anonymous says

    Wow, what is so layered and steeped in family developmental stages summed up beautifully . ….this gives the individual a great deal to think about and resonates to me as a story as old as time. This is a remarkable tool ( your series) …grateful ❤️

    Reply
  7. D Cumpian, Counseling, Eagle Pass, TX, USA says

    Confronting a belief that rules the person’s life requires great skill and patience from the therapist part.
    Thank you!

    Reply
  8. Arva S, Psychotherapy, IN says

    This video is awesome! I love the way Janina Fisher has elaborated on unworthiness and how to tackle it with ease. To top it even there is a script of the video.

    Thank you very much for these wonderful videos and infographics. They help me lot in my practice. Love you all.

    Lot of gratitude to NICABM and all the experienced practitioners who give away fantastic content for free for us private practitioners.

    Reply
  9. Meg G, Another Field, GB says

    Deeply insightful, brilliant in fact. This interview with Dr Janina Fisher explains very clearly where the core sense of unworthiness comes from. It makes total sense. Thank you.

    Reply
  10. Lisa B., Nursing, Spokane, WA, USA says

    From a psychodynamic/psychoanalytic perspective, would Fisher’s description of trauma and unworthiness reflect splitting of self/other and the client being bad or contaminated with badness?

    Reply
    • Arva S, Psychotherapy, IN says

      A great question. Would definitely want to explore this. Seeing it from Internal Family Systems lens may help.

      Reply
  11. Daisy Zoll, Other, GB says

    SO powerful, thank you. Why is it not obvious that there’s more than one story?
    Good to get a reminder.

    Reply
  12. Elena Jones, Other, Pasadena , CA, USA says

    Feeling of unworthiness is a deeply rooted sensation in my body. When I look inside for an image of it, I see it smeared on the walls of the crack in my body along the heart. The crack is an internalized parental divorce at the age of 4. Unworthiness is my nervous system response to the shock of their split. Split that sent me into submit and shame response. Four decades later I started a healing process using many different modalities. Different energies coming up from the bottom of the crack up my body and I have been slowly healing an old wound and many that piled up on top. I am curios how does unworthiness feels and looks in other trauma survivors’ bodies.

    Thank you NICABM for great programs, infographics, resources, and all you do to help trauma survivors to heal.

    Reply
    • Elyse Graf, Social Work, CA says

      Thank you for sharing. I liked how you articulated the trauma as a crack in your body along the heart. To me it makes me want to withdraw, I feel unworthy to be a part of things or less than others. I pull myself out of that and remind myself that I too deserve healing, respect and to feel good in life despite past experiences

      Reply
  13. hannah sherebrin, Psychotherapy, CA says

    This came right in time, since I have 2 clients that fit the description. I may send them the transcript, since they both talk about being worthless. And I do say “not in my way of looking at you. For me you ate a worthy person, that is why I stick with you” but explaining it is a thought rather than feeling, and it was a good survival mechanism is briliant.

    Reply
  14. Srishti Nigam, Medicine, CA says

    A ,Novel idea that “IT” the ‘feeling of unworthiness’ is not a feeling really bet it is a Belief! wow and then one is offered another point of view, so there is a choice now ,to agree or not to agree.Trauma takes the choice away though.It is brilliant the way dr janina Fisher introduces this process to the mind of the patient and then the possibility of Empowerment and transformation. phenomenal.

    Reply
  15. Nicole Mahl, Health Education, AU says

    Thank you.for showing us how Our minds r very clever in how we trick ourselves when we r abused by our caregivers and how these abusive caregivers help make us submissive to their mental illness , until those like u appear to educate and care the victims back to wellness and wholeness. Our society is to often too busy and undereducated to understand what these victims go thru and how they survive in society with others who may also prey upon their vulnerabilities , conditioned values and beliefs that r distorted by abuse Sharing this info helps us be more compassionate re their pain and journey to heal . And how we can be more tolerate of othrs .

    Reply
  16. Tina.R Dodson, Psychotherapy, K.c., MO, USA says

    My clt. has the Freeze with non decision active response. She is an 14 y.o adolescent. We are working with her self esteem confidence & to feel safe with her various environs, grandmom.s care & adoption over the last 2 yrs & transition into 9 th high school, from a special education school in her elementary school years.

    Reply
  17. Christa Wallis, Marriage/Family Therapy, Highland, CA, USA says

    Thank you for this insightful snippet from Dr. Fisher. I consider it progress when a client finally acknowledges that their mind-heart-body did not betray them in the midst of trauma but instead protected them with unique survival strategies. After they accept this reality then we can begin to explore the deeper dynamics of shame, unworthiness and protective layers of denial. I also ‘go to their body’ by establishing first bodily awareness then nervous system regulation-so many people are quite disconnected from their integrated self. I also develop shared understandings of feelings, thinking, emotions, soul and heart. Then we share and communicate in common language about their difficulties so that meanings are resonant and so that new neural pathways are practiced in session and reinforced over and over again. Beautiful offerings NICBAM, much gratitude.

    Reply
    • alena rogers, Marriage/Family Therapy, Des Moines, WA, USA says

      like your style 🙂

      Reply
    • Anonymous, Marriage/Family Therapy, FR says

      I’ve been trying a similar thing with one particular client, as I realized that these are all beliefs and she’s dissociated from her feelings. We’ve been doing a bit of mindfulness and trauma-informed yoga.

      I wonder how helpful Janina Fisher’s question would be for this client. It’s possible that if she had stood up to the bullies, that they would have backed off. Maybe the question for clients like this is more, “what did you fear would happen if you looked at him like he was a bad man”? I’m just brainstorming here…

      Reply
  18. Anne Marr, Another Field, GB says

    Half a century ago my degree studies were simply described as “Child Study.” As a student at a Massachusetts womens’ college the course focused on the works of Piaget, Brunner, Hebb, Skinner, on educational processes both current and historical:early child development as it regards physiological psychology. In the work world university degrees as a measure of personal ability did not ,in my case, translate across all the boards of family backgrounds, experiences,cultural divergencies, I often found that specific informational studies , especially as a young woman, were often counter productive. I felt my studies represented only one small piece of the human behavioural puzzle. Fifty years later, many more years of continuing study and work has reduced my original divisionary approach between therapist/teacher or patient/client. My mentor of over 35 years once said that the most important thing to remember was that anyone who crossed the threshold of my practie came to heal me. So framing a client in accordance to any label, reduces my ability to aid the client’s own ability to embrace real personal change for themselves. REAL change not just the appearance of change. This means opening my horizon beyond formulised boundries,beyond dualistic therapist/client boundries.Without my own daily practices, be they medative,or somatic breaching this duality means a type of co-regulation with my clients which indeed releases both of us from being “stuck” in a response that is neither forced nor synthetic. Thank you for your posted share.

    Reply
    • Jennifer Fortunato, Coach, USA says

      Beautifully said. I will also take your mentor’s words as my own. Thank you.

      Reply
  19. Susan Marshall, Other, Nowhere, NC, USA says

    I disagree. and I live what you talk about and am pulling myself out by myself. I believe I felt worthy enough to stay alive so therefore went into freeze. And it was the secondary layers of living in a freeze state much of my life without realizing it and all the judgments and ridicule that comes with that that caused unworthiness. And I will even take it further, self-destruction for me was about reclaiming my power. I will harm myself before you can kind of thing. you have to live this to understand it.

    Reply
    • Srishti Nigam, Medicine, CA says

      I find that through your creative ,brilliant and little warrior brain/mind, you disarmed and defeated these cruel bigger bodies and brains ; thus survived . However now you are not the same ie.an adult now so they also do not have the same power over you. You can switch over to ‘Thrive state’ from survival state and with appropriate therapy could perhaps allow to self soothe, regenerate and self nurture and eventually grieve you losses from childhood.
      just a suggestion.

      Reply
    • Dakota X, Coach, USA says

      This is resonant with me as I experience nerve pain in response to fear and other unknown unconscious things but always sensed it was some form of self regulation like cutting.. so your response post here is giving me an insight about it… beyond just thinking I’m a masochist… thanks.. yes only those who experience and live it can understand.. for the others it’s just theory

      Reply
  20. Madge Flynn, Psychotherapy, Fayetteville , NY, USA says

    Fisher’s astute articulations are rich with kindness. Beautiful. I agree that collapse is a brilliant survival strategy and when a patient admires their own collapsing as such we can begin the journey to develop new ways to replace the old ways in every way! Once we pay respect to the old ways they can yield and allow new strategies to emerge, i.e. numbing for expression.

    Reply
  21. joy borum, Another Field, USA says

    I’m reminded of something Rollo May? called pseudo-innocence.Thank you and all your colleagues for this and all share. I’m a mediator and spiritual guide and remain grateful for all you all bring to the circle.

    Reply
  22. Sandy Olson, Another Field, Troy, ME, USA says

    When my father left I was three years old. Suddenly my world changed. I had no choice but to retreat behind a mask of indifference which solidified my shame. I was three. My survival depended on my mother who suffered her own shame. I have spent most of my adulthood, fifty years, searching for someone to see me behind my wall. At the bottom of it all is fear and shame. Years of therapy, joining different self help groups etc. . Not until now have I heard words that break through, that make sense. Now I need to find a counselor to help me, to work with me to break down the wall inside. Please take this work seriously. The world needs it.

    Reply
    • borum borum, Another Field, USA says

      Amen, sister. Thank you.

      Reply
  23. CAROL Bayma, Clergy, Norfolk, VA, USA says

    Good morning, Dr. Fisher!
    Your quick lesson above gave me a grin and a bit of joy. “Shame” was an issue which I have addressed with only one of the people whom I have served as a spiritual guide in the past few years. Her age (mid-nineties) and COVID left us no opportunity to pursue it.
    I don’t know that I would have done well with her had we spent more time together, for “feelings of unworthiness” have been an unresolved struggle for me personally through the years. How then could I grin with joy this morning, you may ask.
    Well … as you introduced the topic with the consideration that there might be wisdom behind the response, behold an epiphany. My immediate response was, “Wow! Feeling unworthy kept me from fighting when I was too weak to overcome the situation!” I am certain my elderly friend could have benefitted from such knowledge, but know she is now in a place where she will never again feel unworthy. I thank you that I will have this wisdom to share with others, as needed.
    I keep signing up for these free lectures, etc. even though (at 79) my own doctoral pursuits rarely allow me the time to catch any of the full lectures, but little snippets such as this morning’s, are very helpful. I am grateful to NICABM and all of the participating professionals.
    Blessings on your work,
    Carol

    Reply
    • borum borum, Another Field, USA says

      Thank you, Carol. I, too, am a snippet student, grateful, and still eager to learn, share, and practice.

      Reply
  24. Deirdre Cotter, Psychotherapy, IE says

    When working with a survival adaptive belief, I will usually go to the body to explore where the felt sense of this belief is and more importantly what this part offers the client in terms of managing the trauma at the time but also managing the impact of the trauma right now. Ie what’s ‘good’ about this belief..acknowledgement and inclusion of this adaptive mechanism can usually over time allow space for recognising other parts tgat may have another point of view and may offer a different energy..the main belief can start to be less coupled with the trauma event and over time more and more choice for response can come online.

    Reply
    • borum borum, Another Field, USA says

      Body wisdom, absolutely. And then the words…the power is also in the naming. Thank you for your comment Dierdre.

      Reply

Recent Posts

  • A Strategy to Help Clients Manage Emotional Triggers – with Ruth Lanius, MD, PhD
  • Reporting In – Giving Back in 2022
  • A Polyvagal Approach to Working with Shame – with Stephen Porges, PhD
  • Treating Relational Trauma – with Terry Real, MSW, LICSW
  • Working with Trauma-Induced Shame – with Bessel van der Kolk, MD

Categories

  • Antiracism
  • Anxiety
  • Attachment
  • Body-Oriented Therapy
  • Brain
  • Charity
  • Chronic Pain
  • Compassion
  • COVID-19 Pandemic
  • Depression
  • Exercise and Mental Health
  • Fear
  • Healing Trauma
  • Infographics
  • Mindfulness
  • Nervous System
  • Neuroplasticity
  • Perfectionism
  • PTSD
  • Relationships
  • Resentment
  • Shame
  • Spirituality
  • Trauma
  • Trauma Therapy
  • Unworthiness

40 Wilbur Cross Way Suite 102
Storrs, CT 06268
(860) 477-1450

NICABM Logo

About Us
FAQs
Contact Us
Courses
Claim CE/CMEs
Accreditation
ADA Accommodation
Hiring
SITEMAP PRIVACY POLICY TERMS OF USE

CONNECT WITH US

Facebook Logo YouTube Logo Twitter Logo Instagram Logo

40 Wilbur Cross Way, Suite 102
Storrs, CT 06268
Phone: (860) 477-1450
Fax: (860) 423-4512
respond@nicabm.com
Copyright © 2023

Share this ArticleLike this article? Email it to a friend!

Email sent!